Take-Two Interactive Software, Inc.

TTWO

Take-Two Interactive Software, Inc.

@david
• 21 hours ago

GTA VI just scored a 99. Is it already in the stock price?

GTA VI - Extended Look video

Grand Theft Auto VI comes out tomorrow, and the early reviews are in: a 99 out of 100 on Metacritic. Take-Two’s stock jumped about 7% on the news, and Barron’s called it another reason to buy.

I’ve never seen this much hype around a game. But back in July [JULY POST LINK] I wrote that the game sales were already priced in, and that the real upside was a new GTA Online nobody had announced. So I went back and did the homework. How big could GTA VI be for Take-Two, and how much of that is already in the price?


How big was the last one?

Huge. When GTA V launched in 2013 it topped $800 million in sales on its first day. Take-Two’s revenue went from $1.2 billion to $2.35 billion in one year. One game doubled the company.

Pretty cool. Then I guessed what happened the year after, and I guessed wrong. I figured it kept growing. It didn’t. Revenue fell to $1.08 billion, lower than before the game came out. Part of that drop is accounting timing, but even by the company’s own preferred math it fell by about a third.

And that hangover happened EVEN WITH the launch of GTA Online two weeks after GTA V launched (see below). Take Two has not announced when GTA VI Online will be available.

Lesson one: the year after a GTA is a hangover year.


What would it take to double it now?

A lot more than last time. GTA V added about $1.1 billion of revenue. Take-Two is a much bigger company today, with $6.66 billion of revenue last year, so a double means GTA VI adds about $6.7 billion. That’s nearly six GTA Vs.

Nobody is forecasting that. Take-Two’s own forecast for this fiscal year, GTA VI included, is about $8 billion to $8.2 billion. That’s a 20% year. Wall Street expects more, and management has a habit of forecasting low, but the company itself is telling you to expect roughly one more GTA V on top of a company five times the size.


Two things that make me skeptical

First, the repeat money. I need to understand how they get recurring revenue from GTA VI, so they aren’t trying to hold these numbers up with a one-time purchase.

Last time, GTA Online switched on two weeks after launch, and revenue still fell the next year. This time GTA VI launches as a single-player game, Take-Two hasn’t put a date on a new online mode, and the reporting points to 2027. That’s the same thing I was waiting on in July. Still waiting.

Second, the profit. In what it calls a record year, Take-Two expects to earn $109 million to $142 million. On $8 billion of sales, that’s about a penny and a half on the dollar. In the same forecast it plans to hand employees $462 million in stock. Stock pay that’s more than three times the profit is sketchy. (To be fair, another $623 million of this year’s costs is past acquisitions, mostly Zynga, still being written off. No cash goes out the door for that.)


So what’s it worth?

I ran three cases through my usual model: ten years of cash, a 5% discount rate, and a 30% margin of safety.

  • Bear: GTA VI lands on the company’s forecast, a hangover follows, and Online slips. About $63 a share.

  • Base: it beats the forecast the way last year did, and Online shows up in 2027 at about today’s size. About $174 a share.

  • Bull: Wall Street’s numbers come true and Online is twice as big. About $488 a share.

The stock is around $218. So today’s price is above my base case and needs something close to the bull case, and the bull case depends on an online mode with no release date.

My buy-below price is about $122. And none of those cases counts the stock pay as a cost. If you count it, the base case drops to about $101.


Final Thoughts

GTA VI is probably going to be a great game and the biggest launch ever (I already have it preloaded).

That’s not the same thing as a great stock at this price. There’s a lot of risk riding on it being a complete hit, and a 99 is what everybody already expected.

For me this is a wait-and-see. I’m watching three things: the first real sales numbers, a date for the new GTA Online, and whether the company raises its forecast in February.

If you’ve done the work on Take-Two and see it differently, tell me where I’m wrong.

Disclosure: I don’t own TTWO.

Sentiment: Neutral, wait-and-see